• Classic Hollywood
  • Was ‘Twice Blessed’ (1945) Really the First ‘Parent Trap’?

    Twice Blessed-Parent Trap Connection

    The Twice Blessed–Parent Trap comparison is more than just a fan theory. After all, MGM’s 1945 comedy Twice Blessed revolves around separated identical twins, divorced parents, a secret identity swap, and a reunion scheme. Sound familiar, doesn’t it?

    Twice Blessed came out 16 years before Disney released their first version of The Parent Trap. While the similarities in both films are striking, the real history of these two films indicates that no, The Parent Trap wasn’t based on Twice Blessed… regardless of how similar the two movies are!


    Twice Blessed’s Familiar Premise

    Twice Blessed (1945)
    Source: Screenshot/Canva Edit

    Spoilers follow for both Twice Blessed (1945) and The Parent Trap movies.

    Twice Blessed centers on identical twin sisters who have been separated since their parents’ divorce. One twin, Terry Turner (Lee Wilde), lives with her newspaper reporter father, Jeff Turner (Preston Foster). Meanwhile, the other twin, Stephanie Hale (Lyn Wilde), lives with her mother, prominent child psychologist Mary Hale (Gail Patrick).

    When the sisters reunite after seven years apart, they quickly decide to trade identities to live with their other parent. Already, that sounds rather similar to The Parent Trap. However, Twice Blessed goes even further.

    The wildly different sisters get to experience the other’s lives for a bit, all while fooling their parents. Eventually, they decide to use this time acting as each other to push their parents, Jeff and Mary, back together. 

    Ultimately, the scheme helps to derail Mary’s intended engagement to Senator John Pringle (Richard Gaines) — and clears the way for the twins’ parents to truly reconcile and admit they still love each other.


    Why People Think Twice Blessed & The Parent Trap Are the Same

    Twice Blessed (1945): Gail Patrick - Preston Foster
    Source: Screenshot/Canva Edit

    Clearly, there’s a lot in common between Twice Blessed and The Parent Trap.

    Let’s now look at 1961’s Disney film. The Parent Trap follows separated twins Sharon McKendrick (Hayley Mills) and Susan Evers (again played by Mills) when they meet at a summer camp without initially realizing they are sisters.

    Eventually, they learn that their divorced parents divided the family when the girls were only infants. Sharon went to grow up with Margaret “Maggie” McKendrick (Maureen O’Hara), and Susan went to live with their father, Mitchell “Mitch” Evers (Brian Keith).

    Once the twins discover the truth, they decide to switch their identities, one acting like the other, so that they can meet the parent they’ve never known. This also leads to the two manipulating events and getting their parents back together.

    The major pieces in Twice Blessed and The Parent Trap are almost identical. We have divorced parents, identical twins living separately, twins having dramatically different personalities, a twin identity swap, and children trying to repair their divorced parents’ relationship.

    However, it’s also worth noting that there are significant differences between the two movies. In Twice Blessed, Terry and Stephanie already know they are sisters. They have a relationship, even if they don’t live together. The 1945 film is more of a teenage screwball comedy — full of boyfriends and dance contests — than The Parent Trap.


    The Parent Trap Wasn’t Based on Twice Blessed

    Twice Blessed (1945): Gail Patrick
    Source: Screenshot/Canva Edit

    Regardless of how similar the two films are, The Parent Trap actually wasn’t based on Twice Blessed. Though the films strongly resemble one another, The Parent Trap was actually inspired by the 1949 German novel Das doppelte Lottchen by Erich Kästner. 

    Kästner’s 1949 novel predates Twice Blessed. Interestingly, official research has traced Kästner’s concept to 1937 when he offered a film to Robert Lantz, then working with 20th Century Fox. At the time, Shirley Temple was envisioned as playing the role of twins.

    Around 1942-1943, Kästner again developed the material into a film treatment in Germany. However, renewed Nazi restrictions on his writing prevented his work from moving forward. It wasn’t until after the war was over that he reworked the story into his 1949 novel.


    So, Was Twice Blessed the First Parent Trap?

    No, Twice Blessed therefore wasn’t the first Parent Trap — even though it remains a very similar story. 

    Do you think Twice Blessed deserves to be remembered as the unofficial first Parent Trap? Have you seen the movie — did you like it? We thought it was a nice little family comedy! Comment with all your thoughts and opinions below!

    For more stories from Hollywood’s Golden Age, return to Soapy Tea daily!

    FEATURED IMAGE: SCREENSHOT/CANVA EDIT

    Lilli Glover

    Lilli Glover is an avid General Hospital watcher and a Soapy Tea collaborator.
    4 mins