• Classic Hollywood
  • Top 10 Best Irene Dunne Movies, Ranked

    Best Irene Dunne Movies

    The best Irene Dunne movies show why she remains one of the greatest and most versatile stars of Old Hollywood. Dunne was equally as convincing in screwball comedies, romantic melodramas, and large-scale musicals. There was seemingly nothing she couldn’t do.

    Dunne received five Academy Award nominations for Best Actress, yet never received a win, making her one of the most acclaimed performers of the Golden Age of Hollywood who never took home a competitive acting Oscar.

    Though she might not be as well known today as she was in her heyday, Dunne remains one of the greatest actresses in Hollywood history. Below, we’ve ranked her 10 best films, including one Honorable Mention.

    Note: The descriptions of the movies below cover basic premises. However, they avoid major ending spoilers.


    Honorable Mention: Cimarron (1931)

    Cimarron (1931): Irene Dunne
    Source: Wikimedia Commons/Canva Edit

    Genre: Western

    Starring: Richard Dix, Irene Dunne, Estelle Taylor

    Directed by: Wesley Ruggles

    Cimarron was one of Dunne’s first major Hollywood successes — and earned her her first Best Actress Oscar nomination. As a result, we chose to include this movie as an Honorable Mention.

    Cimarron casts Dunne as Sabra Cravat, a woman who follows her restless husband Yancey Cravat (Dix) to Oklahoma during the territory’s rapid development. This 1931 western, which is a sprawling adaptation of the Edna Ferber classic, has some dated elements that can’t be ignored. It hasn’t stood the test of time as some of Dunne’s other films have. Hence, why it’s only an Honorable Mention.


    10. A Guy Named Joe (1943)

    A Guy Named Joe (1943): Irene Dunne, Spencer Tracy
    Source: Wikimedia Commons/Canva Edit

    Genre: Romantic Fantasy Drama

    Starring: Spencer Tracy, Irene Dunne, Van Johnson

    Directed by: Victor Fleming

    In this sentimental MGM production, World War II romance meets supernatural fantasy — and it’s quite enjoyable! A Guy Named Joe follows daredevil pilot Pete Sandidge (Tracy) after he dies. In death, he becomes an unseen mentor to young aviator Ted Randall (Johnson)… only to later discover that Ted is falling for Pete’s former girlfriend, Dorinda Durston (Dunne)!

    This is a sentimental wartime picture, yet it’s also one of the best Irene Dunne movies of all time.


    9. Roberta (1935)

    Genre: Musical + Romantic Comedy

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers, Randolph Scott

    Directed by: William A. Seiter

    While most people may remember 1935’s Roberta today because of Astaire and Rogers and their delightful chemistry, it’s not like Dunne is overshadowed in this film at all. How could she be?

    Dunne plays Princess Stephanie, an exiled Russian aristocrat working at an upscale Paris fashion house where she becomes involved with American John Kent (Scott). This fun musical features great Jerome Kern standards, including “Yesterdays” and “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes.”

    RELATED: Is ‘Primrose Path’ Ginger Rogers’ Most Underrated Movie?


    8. Theodora Goes Wild (1936)

    Genre: Screwball Romantic Comedy

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Melvyn Douglas, Thomas Mitchell

    Directed by: Richard Boleslawski

    Theodora Goes Wild was the first movie that proved that Dunne could handle screwball comedy as easily as she did prestige drama. This 1936 delight follows Theodora Lynn (Dunne) as he maintains a respectable existence in a small, conservative Connecticut town. Secretly, she’s writing a scandalous bestseller under the name of Caroline Adams!

    When illustrator Michael Grant (Douglas) discovers that there is considerably more to Theodora than her small-town image might suggest, both characters begin challenging the other’s carefully managed life. And it’s all to great fun.

    Dunne’s turn from drama to comedy earned her a second Best Actress Oscar nomination. Theodora Goes Wild is also one of the best Irene Dunne movies of all time!


    7. Show Boat (1936)

    Genre: Musical + Drama

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Allan Jones, Charles Winninger

    Directed by: James Whale

    Show Boat remains an essential entry among the best Irene Dunne movies. In this adaptation of the Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein II musical, Dunne plays Magnolia Hawks, the daughter of a showboat operator, Cap’n Andy Hawks (Winninger).

    Her life changes after she meets gambler and performer Gaylord Ravenal (Jones) — and it’s riveting to watch. The film also includes delightful performances by Paul Robeson and Helen Morgan!


    6. Life with Father (1947)

    Genre: Comedy

    Starring: William Powell, Irene Dunne, Elizabeth Taylor

    Directed by: Michael Curtiz

    Set in 1880s New York, Life with Father follows a stubborn family patriarch, Clarence Day Sr. (Powell), and his considerably more diplomatic wife, Vinnie Day (Dunne). While Powell gets the title role here, the movie wouldn’t be the same without Dunne! As a result, Life with Father is definitely one of the best Irene Dunne movies of all time!


    5. Penny Serenade (1941)

    Penny Serenade (1941): Cary Grant - Irene Dunne
    Source: Wikimedia Commons/Canva Edit

    Genre: Romantic Drama

    Starring: Cary Grant, Irene Dunne, Beulah Bondi

    Directed by: George Stevens

    When it comes to Grant and Dunne’s movie collaborations, most people think of their comedies. Penny Serenade is their one and only drama — and they are riveting together here.

    In Penny Serenade, Julie Gardiner Adams (Dunne) looks back on her marriage to newspaper reporter Roger Adams (Grant). A collection of records triggers memories of the couple’s relationship, as well as their attempts to build a family.

    Topics in the film include loss, parenthood, and financial pressure — and how all of this can strain a loving marriage. A must-watch.


    4. I Remember Mama (1948)

    Genre: Drama

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Barbara Bel Geddes, Oscar Homolka

    Directed by: George Stevens

    In I Remember Mama, Dunne delivered one of her most restrained performances. In this 1948 drama, she plays Marta Hanson, the Norwegian-born matriarch of a working-class family in early-20th-century San Francisco. 

    The film is told through the memories of her daughter, Katrin Hanson (Bel Geddes). Drama ensues in the form of family disputes, money problems, illnesses, and daily chaos. Dunne is marvelous — which isn’t a surprise — and her performance here earned her her fifth and final Best Actress Oscar nomination.


    3. Love Affair (1939)

    Love Affair (1939): Irene Dunne - Charles Boyer
    Source: Wikimedia Commons/Canva Edit

    Genre: Romantic Drama

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Charles Boyer, Maria Ouspenskaya

    Directed by: Leo McCarey

    Before An Affair to Remember, there was Love Affair. In this 1939 romantic drama, Terry McKay (Dunne) and French artist Michel Marnet (Boyer) meet aboard an ocean liner while both are attached to other people. However, their attraction develops into real affection.

    They promise to reunite months later, at the top of the Empire State Building, after they put their existing lives in order. Dunne and Boyer’s chemistry really sells this picture, and for many people (including us), Love Affair is the best version of this often-told story.

    Dunne received a Best Actress Oscar nomination for her work here, and it’s well deserved. As a result, Love Affair is certainly one of the best Irene Dunne movies of all time!

    RELATED — The Top 10 Best Charles Boyer Movies, Ranked


    2. My Favorite Wife (1940)

    Genre: Screwball Romantic Comedy

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Cary Grant, Randolph Scott

    Directed by: Garson Kanin

    And now, for some fun. Few screen couples could turn marital chaos into comedy so effortlessly. But that’s exactly what Dunne and Grant did here.

    My Favorite Wife follows Ellen Arden (Dunne), who is presumed dead after disappearing at sea. However, when she unexpectedly returns home, she discovers that her husband, Nick Arden (Grant), has just remarried! Complications multiply when Nick learns that Ellen was stranded for years with the handsome Stephen Burkett (Scott). It’s ridiculous, but it’s great!


    1. The Awful Truth (1937)

    The Awful Truth (1937): Ralph Bellamy, Cary Grant, Irene Dunne
    Source: Wikimedia Commons/Canva Edit

    Genre: Screwball Romantic Comedy

    Starring: Irene Dunne, Cary Grant, Ralph Bellamy

    Directed by: Leo McCarey

    The Awful Truth is the very best Irene Dunne movie of all time. How could it not be? This 1937 screwball rom-com tells the love story of Lucy Warriner (Dunne) and Jerry Warriner (Grant). 

    When the two impulsively decide to divorce after each suspects the other of infidelity, they quickly realize that they might not be fully over the other. Both Lucy and Jerry find that neither of them is remotely prepared to watch the other actually move on. Screwball-esque drama, jealousy, sabotage, and chaos ensue.

    Dunne earned another Best Actress nomination for her work here. The Awful Truth remains one of the most beloved screwball rom-coms of all time, and for good reason! It’s great!


    Watch the Best Irene Dunne Movies Today

    As you can see, the best Irene Dunne movies cover just about every major genre Old Hollywood offered. Dunne was able to shift between comedy and drama, and all without losing control of the screen or her audience.

    So, what is your favorite Dunne movie? Which would you put at the No. 1 spot? Hit the comments below with all your thoughts! We’d love to hear what you think!

    For the latest Old Hollywood rankings and lists, return to Soapy Tea daily!

    FEATURED IMAGE: WIKIMEDIA COMMONS/CANVA EDIT

    Diane Bowen

    Diane Bowen is a writer for Soapy Tea and a long-time Days of Our Lives fan.
    8 mins