No The Goose and the Gander review is complete without first mentioning how bizarre it is. And not necessarily in a bad way. This 1935 romantic comedy somehow manages to bring together adulterous lovers, a delightfully scheming ex-wife, jewel thieves on the run, and a police showdown, all under one roof. Everyone has a reason to lie — and they all do.
If you just go along with it, it’s quite fun!
Directed by Alfred E. Green, The Goose and the Gander is a short 65-minute Warner Bros. romantic comedy starring the incomparable Kay Francis opposite George Brent, one of her frequent leading men. The ensemble cast is rounded out by the absolutely charming Genevieve Tobin, plus Claire Dodd, Ralph Forbes, and John Eldredge.
Nearly 90 years later, and this movie’s primary attraction remains the same. Its characters behave terribly. Yet that’s actually quite funny — and the film knows that.
Minor premise spoilers follow. However, no major ending spoilers will be in this The Goose and the Gander review.
The Goose and the Gander Is All About a Trap

The Goose and the Gander follows Georgiana Summers (Kay Francis) as she discovers that Betty Summers (Genevieve Tobin) — the woman who married Georgiana’s former husband, Ralph Summers (Ralph Forbes) — is planning a romantic weekend with Robert “Bob” McNear (George Brent).
Rather than warn Ralph, Georgiana decides to manufacture a situation in which he can discover Betty’s behavior himself. Her scheme eventually brings Betty and Bob to a mountain cabin near Santa Barbara. Georgiana intends to keep them there until Ralph himself arrives to see what his new wife has been up to.
That’s already enough material for a conventional marital farce. But then, The Goose and the Gander kicks it up a notch by having Lawrence Thurston (John Eldredge) and Connie Thurston (Claire Dodd) arrive.
They’re jewel thieves. Of course.
The criminals have stolen Betty’s automobile as part of their getaway, as the police are onto them. Their arrival at the cabin creates an additional layer of mistaken identities and lies. Before long, it’s clear that the cheating couple cannot explain themselves without exposing their affair. Meanwhile, the thieves cannot explain themselves without exposing their crimes. Finally, Georgiana cannot reveal everything without destroying her very carefully constructed revenge plot.
The Goose and the Gander is a collection of misbehaving characters whose secrets leave nobody in a position to accuse anybody else. It’s grand fun, if you allow it to be.
RELATED: The Top 10 Best George Brent Movies, Ranked
Kay Francis Holds All the Chaos Together

What keeps The Goose and the Gander from becoming exhausting is its speed. The movie lasts only 65 minutes, thankfully, and it seems as if a new complication is introduced every few scenes. That’s key to making the film work, even when it does fall flat in certain areas.
Even back in 1935, contemporary critics recognized this. New York Times critic Andre Sennwald even wrote that the story was almost mechanically constructed. However, Sennwald still concluded that the elaborate scrambling of all of the characters worked effectively as a minor farce.
Francis is, of course, crucial to making this machinery entertaining. Her Georgiana isn’t an innocent surrounded by all of these dishonest people. She’s another participant, even if her motives were rather purer than the rest. However, she is working from a point of revenge — and revenge requires manipulation and strategic withholding of information, all of which she does. She’s on the same morally flexible playing field as everyone else, whether she likes it or not.
The Goose and the Gander also gives Francis a welcome comic role. Rather than playing Georgiana as wounded or incredibly melodramatic, Francis gets to remain poised while deliberately making everyone around her increasingly uncomfortable. All along the way, she’s rather enchanting to watch.
George Brent works well as Bob, whose affair with Tobin’s Betty puts him at the center of Georgiana’s increasingly complicated trap. Meanwhile, Tobin gives Betty exactly the nervous self-interest the scenario requires. It wouldn’t be a surprise if you walk away from this film being absolutely enchanted by Tobin’s work.
Perhaps one of the best things about this film is that it never waits for one misunderstanding to be resolved before introducing another. The misunderstandings just pile on top of one another.
A Post-Code Comedy That’s Rather Risqué

The Goose and the Gander is also intriguing because of when it was released. Stricter enforcement of Hollywood’s Production Code had taken hold by the time this film was made in 1935. The Code limited how openly mainstream films could handle topics like adultery and sexual relationships.
Yet somehow, The Goose and the Gander manages to build its entire comic structure around infidelity and improper appearances anyway. While there’s no outrageously explicit material here, it’s still very interesting to see how a post-Code movie could get away with more than one would think!
If not for anything else, this alone makes the film worth rediscovering.
RELATED: The Top 10 Best Kay Francis Movies, Ranked
The Goose and the Gander Review: This Film Deserves Another Look

The Goose and the Gander isn’t a perfect film by any means. However, it’s hard not to be at least slightly delighted by all of its machinations. Somehow, the movie takes the relatively simple revenge premise and escalates it until romance, adultery, theft, and mistaken identity are all major points in a 65-minute film.
It isn’t one of the 1930s canonical screwball comedies, nor is it likely ever on anyone’s top 10 lists. However, viewers interested in Kay Francis or compact 1930s studio filmmaking should find plenty to enjoy here.
Hit the comments below with all your thoughts on this film! Have you seen it, and did you like it? What did you think of our The Goose and the Gander review? Comment all your opinions below! We’d love to hear what you think!
For more forgotten Hollywood movie reviews and Old Hollywood content, return to Soapy Tea daily!
FEATURED IMAGE: SCREENSHOT/CANVA EDIT



