The Keyhole’s (1933) casting history is very interesting, to say the least, especially when you learn that none other than William Powell was originally announced for the lead romantic role eventually played by George Brent.
According to AFI, Warner Bros. wanted Powell to star in the film before they eventually changed course. As a result, instead of The Keyhole becoming another collaboration between Francis and Powell, it became the first screen pairing of Francis and Brent.
This is one of those casting changes that becomes more interesting once you watch the film. Brent plays Neil Davis, a private detective who also becomes a romantic pursuer of his target. It was the kind of role that Powell would’ve excelled at playing.
William Powell Was Supposed to Star in The Keyhole (1933)

It’s not like putting Powell opposite Francis would have been experimental. After all, the prolific duo had already made six movies together between just 1930 and 1932 alone, beginning with 1930’s Behind the Make-Up and ending with the fantastic One Way Passage from 1932.
One Way Passage was Powell and Francis’ sixth and final collaboration — and their biggest commercial hit. If Powell had ultimately made The Keyhole, the movie would have reunited one of the early sound era’s established romantic teams immediately after their most successful collaboration. It would’ve been interesting to see, to say the least.
Of course, for many Powell fans, there is no one they’d rather see him with than his frequent collaborator, Myrna Loy. However, don’t sleep on the movies Powell and Francis made together. While they don’t have that spark that Powell and Loy movies have, they’re still very enjoyable.
Would Powell Have Made Neil Davis More Convincing?

Major spoilers for The Keyhole follow.
In this 1933 romance, Anne Vallee Brooks (Francis) learns that her former husband and dancing partner, Maurice Le Brun (Monroe Owsley), never completed the divorce she sought. That makes things rather complicated for her, as she has since married Schuyler Brooks (Henry Kolker).
As a result of this deception, her marriage to the wealthy Schuyler has become legally compromised… and this gives Maurice exactly what he needs to blackmail Anne. Anne decides to sail to Cuba, hoping Maurice will follow. Then, her friend Portia Brooks (Helen Ware) will arrange for the U.S. to bar him from returning to the country.
However, Schuyler is suspicious of Anne’s behavior. He hires a private detective, Neil Davis (Brent), to secretly follow her. He doesn’t initially tell Neil that Anne is his wife.
On the ocean liner, Neil approaches Anne under false pretenses. Basically, his whole job is to try to seduce her — and then report back to her husband that yes, his suspicions were correct: he’s married to a lady who cheats on him. However, Anne resists Neil’s advances, and Neil has no choice but to write back to her husband on this… while he’s secretly falling for her himself.
Along the way, despite all odds, Anne and Neil fall in love. By the end of the movie, she leaves her husband for him. An interesting pre-code, isn’t it? Much more happens in the film, but let’s return to how Powell could have changed all of this.
Neil is supposed to be charming enough that Anne would fall in love with him and choose to be with him, even after she discovers that he’s been spying on her this whole time for her husband. He also has to be able to seamlessly move between romantic leading man and investigator. Who better than Powell could pull this off?
After all, only months after The Keyhole was released, Powell starred in Private Detective 62, which follows a private investigator who falls for the woman he has been assigned to watch. Clearly, this character isn’t so far-fetched for Powell. Powell could have definitely played him.
The Keyhole had mixed contemporary reviews. A TIME review from the period of the movie’s release identified a tonal weakness, stating that the sentimental romance didn’t seamlessly work with Neil’s professional spying. However, the reviewer did applaud Francis’ charm.
Powell’s ability to work within these types of tonal differences might have made the movie easier to sell.
RELATED: Top 10 Best Kay Francis Movies, Ranked
George Brent’s Casting Did Have a Major Upside

Let’s be clear: George Brent’s casting in The Keyhole was no mistake. Though the movie might not work in many areas — nobody will say it’s one of the greatest films ever — it’s still an interesting movie to watch, particularly for those who enjoy Francis and Brent films, or pre-code movies.
Brent isn’t terrible in this movie at all. It’s simply interesting to think of what Powell may have brought to The Keyhole if he indeed had starred.
Furthermore, The Keyhole is a notable film, for it was the first movie in the Brent and Francis partnership. The duo would go on to appear in six films together, including Living on Velvet, The Goose and the Gander, and Stranded.
With Brent’s inclusion, rather than Powell’s, The Keyhole also becomes clearly a Francis vehicle. Anne drives the film — not Brent. If Powell indeed had been in the film, it would’ve been less of a straight Francis vehicle, and more of a Powell-Francis picture.
During the time of The Keyhole‘s release, Francis was solidifying her position as one of Warner Bros.’ major female stars. Clearly, Powell not starring in this film benefited her. She was really able to make it her film.
RELATED: Top 10 Best George Brent Movies, Ranked
Would You Have Wanted to See William Powell in The Keyhole?
Many of us may think that The Keyhole would’ve been a better film if Powell had starred. We may indeed be some of those people. However, for all of us who think that, there are others who very much appreciate Brent’s role in the film.
Plus, how could we do without the partnership that became Brent and Francis?
What do you think? Do you think Powell would have made The Keyhole a better movie? Or do you prefer Francis with Brent? Hit the comments below with all your opinions and thoughts!
Plus, always be sure to return to Soapy Tea for more classic Hollywood news and forgotten casting stories!
FEATURED IMAGE: SCREENSHOT/CANVA EDIT



