A list of the top 10 best Margaret Sullavan movies gives you a little bit of everything. A little bit of romantic melodrama that leaves you devastated by the time the credits roll. Perhaps even a little bit of sophisticated romantic comedy that leaves you feeling lighter than before. Sullavan was, perhaps more so than any other actress of her time, one of the most natural stars during the Golden Age of Hollywood.
Though a bit forgotten now, Sullavan was — and is — riveting to watch in the few films she left behind. Though her screen career was rather brief, as she preferred the stage, Sullavan’s movie collaborations with Ernst Lubitsch, William Wyler, Frank Borzage, and more prove just what a star she was.
When it came to ranking the top 10 best Margaret Sullavan movies, we did our best to weigh her performance alongside the overall movie quality, Sullavan’s role within it, and the lasting reputation of the film itself.
Here, you’ll find her very first feature film alongside her best, as Sullavan entered Hollywood already prepared to create fantastic movies!
Film synopses are spoiler-free.
- 10. Back Street (1941)
- 9. So Ends Our Night (1941)
- 8. The Shopworn Angel (1938)
- 7. Little Man, What Now? (1934)
- 6. Only Yesterday (1933)
- 5. Cry ‘Havoc’ (1943)
- 4. The Good Fairy (1935)
- 3. Three Comrades (1938)
- 2. The Mortal Storm (1940)
- 1. The Shop Around the Corner (1940)
- Watch the Best Margaret Sullavan Movies Today
10. Back Street (1941)
Genre: Romantic Drama
Starring: Charles Boyer, Margaret Sullavan, Richard Carlson
Directed by: Robert Stevenson
Back Street has been filmed many times over the decades. We all have our own personal favorite. Even if you prefer Irene Dunne’s 1932 version, don’t sleep on the 1941 movie, particularly because it united Sullavan with Charles Boyer. Sullavan and Boyer’s on-screen chemistry is not something to miss!
Back Street follows Ray Smith (Sullavan) and Walter Saxel (Boyer) as they fall in love. However, Walter’s existing obligations — and eventual marriage to another woman — leave their relationship one that remains outside of conventional respectability. Simply, Ray becomes his secret mistress.
This film is unmistakably a romantic melodrama, but Sullavan and Boyer’s performances — and chemistry — make this one to watch even if you don’t particularly like melodramas. Definitely one of the best Margaret Sullavan movies of all time.
RELATED: Top 10 Best Charles Boyer Movies, Ranked
9. So Ends Our Night (1941)
Genre: Romantic War Drama
Starring: Fredric March, Margaret Sullavan, Frances Dee, Glenn Ford
Directed by: John Cromwell
If you’re looking for a great European political drama from the Old Hollywood age to watch, put on So Ends Our Night. This 1941 romantic war drama follows refugees without valid passports as they move across a Europe that becomes increasingly hostile to them.
Along the way, Ruth Holland (Sullavan) becomes romantically involved with Ludwig Kern (Ford), while Josef Steiner (March) struggles to face his existence in exile. Truly one of the best Margaret Sullavan movies of all time.
8. The Shopworn Angel (1938)
Genre: Romantic Drama
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, Walter Pidgeon
Directed by: H.C. Potter
There is something very special about a Sullavan-Stewart collaboration. The two had already worked together in 1936 when they reunited again for 1938’s The Shopworn Angel. Their on-screen chemistry would eventually peak in 1940’s The Shop Around the Corner, which we’ll discuss later.
Don’t sleep on The Shopworn Angel, though. This 1938 World War I romance follows cynical Broadway performer Daisy Heath (Sullavan) who meets naive serviceman Bill Pettigrew (Stewart) right before he is sent overseas during the war. Initially, Daisy treats Bill’s infatuation with her rather casually, as she is in love with her manager Sam Bailey (Pidgeon).
Sam, meanwhile, watches as their unlikely connection develops. The film remains interesting because Sullavan doesn’t necessarily soften Daisy. Daisy is complicated, yet changes from the beginning of the film by the time the tragic end rolls around. Sullivan and Stewart’s chemistry makes this one to watch, but Pidgeon is also great. As a result, we can’t help but feel that this is surely one of the best Margaret Sullavan movies of all time!
7. Little Man, What Now? (1934)
Genre: Romantic Drama
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, Douglass Montgomery, Alan Hale
Directed by: Frank Borzage
Little Man, What Now? tells the story of an intimate marriage struggling to survive amid economic instability in Germany. Sullavan and Montgomery play Emma and Hans, a young couple doing their best to save their relationship while poverty, unemployment, and other social pressures surround them.
It’s a great emotional drama that is made even better by Sullavan’s performance. Little Man, What Now? was made only a year after her debut in Only Yesterday, and yet it feels as if Sullavan has decades’ worth of experience here. A must-watch.
6. Only Yesterday (1933)
Genre: Romantic Drama
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, John Boles, Edna May Oliver
Directed by: John M. Stahl
Sullavan made her feature film debut as Mary Lane in 1933’s Only Yesterday. Unlike other big Old Hollywood stars of her day, there is no sense you get of watching a newcomer find their footing in this movie. No, Sullavan was already a star. As a result, Only Yesterday is definitely one of the best Margaret Sullavan movies of all time!
In this 1933 romantic pre-code drama, Mary Lane falls in love with Jim Emerson (Boles), but circumstances leave the two unable to actually be in a relationship… and Mary Lane, over the years, finds herself thinking the relationship means more to her than it does to him. The film is remarkably similar to 1948’s Letter From an Unknown Woman, but Sullavan and Boles manage to make it shine just on its own.
5. Cry ‘Havoc’ (1943)
Genre: War Drama
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, Ann Sothern, Joan Blondell
Directed by: Richard Thorpe
No list of the best Margaret Sullavan movies would be complete without including Cry ‘Havoc’. This World War II drama centers almost entirely on women who are caught in the siege of Bataan. While the film differs from other WWII-era films in that not too much action is shown, the movie is full of fear, exhaustion, and tension as the fighting occurs around the main characters.
Sullavan plays Lieutenant Mary “Smitty” Smith, an experienced Army nurse who attempts to keep an overwhelmed field hospital in functioning order as the Japanese forces advance through the Philippines.
Things get rough when a shortage of personnel brings in civilian volunteers, including Pat Conlin (Sothern) and Grace Lambert (Blondell).
Though Cry ‘Havoc’, which was released during World War II, inevitably includes some overtly patriotic themes, the fact that it has a predominantly female cast distinguishes it from many of its contemporary pictures.
Notably, this was Sullavan’s final picture for MGM. She wouldn’t make another feature film until her very last, No Sad Songs for Me, in 1950.
4. The Good Fairy (1935)
Genre: Romantic Comedy
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, Herbert Marshall, Frank Morgan
Directed by: William Wyler
Before Preston Sturges became one of the greatest writer-directors of Old Hollywood, he wrote this adaptation for William Wyler. That alone should be why you put on The Good Fairy. Add in the great talents of Sullavan and co., and you’ve got a great little film.
In The Good Fairy, Sullavan plays Luisa Ginglebusher, an innocent young woman who becomes determined to perform good deeds. However, this determination quickly creates an increasingly complicated romantic situation.
Eventually, this leads to the introduction of the idealistic lawyer Dr. Max Sporum (Marshall), as well as a series of misunderstandings. Sullavan is perhaps best known as a dramatic actress. However, The Good Fairy showed just what a sharp comedic performer she could be!
3. Three Comrades (1938)
Genre: Romantic Drama
Starring: Robert Taylor, Margaret Sullavan, Franchot Tone, Robert Young
Directed by: Frank Borzage
Sullavan was nominated for her first and only Academy Award nomination for her excellent performance in Three Comrades. For that alone, this 1938 romantic drama is worth a watch!
Three Comrades centers on former German soldiers Erich Lohkamp (Taylor), Otto Koster (Tone), and Goffried Lenz (Young) whose postwar friendship becomes complicated when Patricia Hollmann (Sullavan) enters their lives — and falls for Erich.
The emotional story revolves around Patricia, who has health problems. However, you get more than just a medical melodrama here. With its stunning ensemble cast and Sullavan’s Academy Award-nominated performance, Three Comrades is one of the best Margaret Sullavan movies of all time, without a doubt.
2. The Mortal Storm (1940)
Genre: Drama
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, Robert Young, Frank Morgan
Directed by: Frank Borzage
The Mortal Storm is a phenomenal film for many reasons. Firstly, it is a truly intriguing story with an excellent cast. Secondly, it was one of the only major Hollywood studio films to confront Nazism directly during this time. The 1940 drama begins as Adolf Hitler becomes the German chancellor, then follows the Roth family in Germany as ideology tears them apart.
Sullavan plays Freya Roth as she watches the people closest to her embrace the new regime. Meanwhile, her longtime friend Martin Breitner (Stewart) rejects Nazism — and suffers the consequences. Freya’s father, Professor Viktor Roth (Morgan), becomes increasingly vulnerable as Nazi racial ideology takes hold of their town and family.
While the film says that Professor Roth is “non-Aryan”, rather than explicitly saying he’s Jewish, it’s clear what the movie is trying to say. The Mortal Storm was one of MGM’s first movies to openly criticize Nazi Germany. As a result, Joseph Goebbels shut down the Berlin office of MGM’s parent company, Loew’s, and banned all MGM films from playing in German-controlled territories.
The Mortal Storm is also the fourth and final film collaboration between Sullavan and Stewart. Truly, this is one of those films you just have to see.
RELATED: 10 Classic War Romance Movies That Deserve More Attention
1. The Shop Around the Corner (1940)
Genre: Romantic Dramedy
Starring: Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, Frank Morgan
Directed by: Ernst Lubitsch
The best Margaret Sullavan movie is 1940’s The Shop Around the Corner. This holiday romance also remains her most beloved and popular movie today.
Ernst Lubitsch’s great romantic comedy showcases Sullavan as Klara Novak, an employee at a Budapest leather-goods store who constantly clashes with her co-worker, Alfred Kralik (Stewart). Neither Klara nor Kralik realizes that the anonymous correspondent each has fallen in love with through the mail is the other.
The premise has been done many times since, most notably in In the Good Old Summertime and You’ve Got Mail. However, it’s hard to forget Lubitsch’s version in 1940. This is one of those Christmas classics that just stay with you — and for good reason.
Watch the Best Margaret Sullavan Movies Today
Sullavan left behind a small body of work. However, so many of her films are highly watchable and engaging, even decades after they were first made. Whether you want to watch a political drama, a romantic melodrama, or a lighthearted comedy, this list of the best Margaret Sullavan movies has it all.
Sullavan, in our opinion, remains one of the most distinctive and natural performers of the Old Hollywood era. So, which film on this list are you going to put on today? Hit the comments below with all your thoughts! Any film you wish we would’ve added here?
For the latest classic Hollywood rankings and other content, return to Soapy Tea daily!
FEATURED IMAGE: WIKIMEDIA COMMONS/CANVA EDIT



